Menu

Going off the rails with overspeeding


Greg Morse

RHSS Editor and Operational Feedback Lead

 

Train driver Tom Clarke was a bit of a celebrity in the 1930s, so much so that the celebrated model maker Hornby used his approval—Driver Clarke says, ‘it’s fine’—as a slogan in their adverts.

Clarke’s claim to fame? Well, in 1936, he drove an express non-stop between London and Glasgow in record time to great acclaim. Then, on 29 June 1937, he took No.6220 ‘Coronation’ up to 114 mph on Madeley Bank, breaking the previous speed record for steam set by a rival company the year before.

The trouble was, this run wasn’t quite so ‘fine’. The train was still running at 110 mph as it got closer and closer to Crewe. Urgent braking helped, but the engine still passed through the station’s 20 mph curves at 57. Track was damaged and passengers were thrown across carriages…but thankfully, amazingly, the train did not derail.

Old story, new conditions

Of course, there have been derailments caused by overspeeding in the past, notably on the tight curve at Morpeth, where it happened in 1969, 1984, and again in 1994.

The solution in those cases centred on using the automatic warning system to warn drivers of the need to slow down. But fast-forward to 2022 and the older stories continue to call to us.

It was on 17 April that year that an express passed over three sets of points at Spital Junction at excessive speed. The maximum permitted speed here is 30 mph, reducing to 25. The train went through at 76. It lurched violently. Some passengers were thrown from their seats. Others were struck by falling luggage.

The Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) said the train was close to a speed that would have led to it overturning. This is dangerously close to the Morpeth derailments, which—between them—killed six people and injured 57 more.

At Spital, the driver had not reacted appropriately to the (diverging) signal indication given on the approach to the junction.

But the train operator had not assessed and controlled the risk associated with trains being unexpectedly directed on to a slower route. And the industry had neither assessed nor effectively controlled the risk associated with the safe integration of new (faster) trains.

Another incident at Spital Junction occurred the following year, with a similar two at Grantham South Junction following in 2025.

RAIB’s recent summary of speeding incidents found that drivers tended to expect to be routed straight ahead rather than across diverging junctions. This means expectation can override observation, potentially causing drivers to misread or fail to react to a junction indicator.

What’s being done

The industry is taking action.

RSSB’s Junction Overspeed Risk Assessment Tool is being used collaboratively between infrastructure managers and operators to identify and prioritise locations where the risk is highest.

A more engaging tool is perhaps the camera, and with this in mind RED75 is taking a close look at speed management. Here, Lumo’s Kevin Thompson talks candidly about his experience at Spital Junction in 2022. He also speaks to other drivers to warn them of the risks of overspeeding, having completed a diploma in coaching and mentoring. Now that really IS fine.