Menu
Project number: T1393

Better managing the health risks linked to silica dust arising from the use of sanders


This project enhances industry’s understanding of the occupational health hazards relating to the replenishment, maintenance, and testing of sanders. It also outlines some potential mitigations that could help to reduce these risks
‘The good practice guide and control risk fact sheet are invaluable and [would benefit] every railway depot.’
Louis Schmandt
Technical Engineer, Chiltern Railways (co-industry sponsor)

The challenge

Braking and traction sand used on trains contains silica. Some of this dust is fine enough to get deep into lungs. This respirable fraction is known as respirable crystalline silica (RCS).

RCS is an occupational health hazard that can lead to lung cancer and other lung conditions. Respirable amorphous silica is non-crystalline but can also irritate the airways.

A trade union raised concerns with a train operating company (TOC) on the occupational health hazards associated with sander replenishment, maintenance, and testing. This issue was escalated to RSSB and discussed at the Adhesion Research Group. The conclusion reached was that the risk, including how sand alternatives compare, was not well understood.

What we did

As a result, we initiated a research project to improve how this risk is understood and managed.

The work involved:

  • depot visits and information gathering to establish a practical evidence base
  • exposure assessments to compare 8-hour time-weighted average results with UK workplace exposure limits (WELs)
  • toxicological assessments to compare sand alternatives
  • development of good practice to raise awareness of the potential health risks associated with RCS and respirable amorphous silica during sanding-related activities and to support depot managers in identifying, assessing, and controlling those exposures.

This research was made possible by in-kind contributions from TOCs, fleet maintainers, and suppliers.

Benefits delivered

The work yielded several key findings. One is that, across the activities sampled, no measured exposures exceeded the relevant WELs.

Also, for respirable amorphous silica, all measured concentrations were below the analytical limit of detection. Measurable RCS was found in some sanding activities, but it never exceeded the WEL of 0.1 milligrams per cubic metre.

The braking and traction sand samples had much higher bulk quartz content than the sand alternatives. This means that, where dust is generated for the former, the main concern is RCS-containing dust.

Depot managers have new resources to better manage silica dust risk, including a good practice guide and control risk fact sheet.

The evidence will reduce the number of exposure monitoring assessments and focus effort in a targeted way.